/ Notes

The payoff the exits allow

Two numbers on almost every strategy report, the profit factor and the win rate, fix a third that the report rarely prints: the average win as a multiple of the average loss. This note checks that number against the one thing that limits it, the strategy’s own exits.

1. The number hiding in two others

Profit factor is gross profit divided by gross loss. With the win rate w beside it, the payoff, average win divided by average loss, is

payoff = profit factor x (1 - w) / w

Take a hypothetical report: 100 trades, 42 winners, profit factor 1.5. The implied payoff is 1.5 x 0.58 / 0.42 = 2.07. Every winner has to average a little more than twice the average loser. The page on what a profit factor tells you works the basic formula through; this note starts where it stops.

2. Exits set a ceiling

Now read the exit rules. Say the description is a fixed bracket: a stop one unit of risk (1R) away and a target 2R away, nothing else. Then no winner can be larger than 2R, and no loser smaller than 1R. The payoff cannot exceed 2.0.

That puts a ceiling on the profit factor too. At a 42% win rate, the most a 2:1 bracket can produce is 0.42 / 0.58 x 2 = 1.45. The report says 1.5. It is a small gap, which is exactly why it gets missed: the claimed figure sits just above what the stated exits can deliver, before a single cent of cost.

3. Costs pull the ceiling down

Costs come out of every trade, winners and losers alike. With a round trip of 0.1R, a 2R winner nets 1.9R and a 1R loser costs 1.1R, so the payoff ceiling falls to 1.9 / 1.1 = 1.73, and the profit factor ceiling at 42% falls to about 1.25. The cost-in-R calculator turns a cost quoted in percent into R for any stop.

So for this report the honest range is not “about 1.5”. The exits it describes allow at most 1.45 before costs and about 1.25 after them.

4. Run it backwards

The same arithmetic answers a different question: given the exits, what win rate does the claimed profit factor need? It is

w = profit factor / (profit factor + payoff)

At a payoff of 2.0, a profit factor of 1.5 needs 42.9% winners. At the after-cost payoff of 1.73, it needs 46.5%. The report shows 42%. Either the win rate is understated, which is rare, or the payoff came from somewhere the description does not mention.

5. Where extra payoff comes from

When the implied payoff is larger than the exits allow, the usual explanations are:

  • Exits the description leaves out. A trailing stop, a time exit or a partial take-profit lets some winners run past the target.
  • Position size that grows with equity. A profit factor in currency weights later trades more heavily than one measured in R.
  • Gaps through the target. A limit target can fill at a better price when the market gaps past it, so a small excess over the ceiling can be genuine. A large one rarely is.
  • Figures from different runs. A profit factor taken from one run and a win rate from another are not tied together by the formula at all.

Costs left out, or left at TradingView’s default of zero, are not on that list. They can explain a figure between the two ceilings, not one above the before-cost ceiling.

6. Averages hide the shape

The implied payoff is a ratio of averages, and an average can be carried by one trade. A second hypothetical report: 50 trades, 18 winners at 1.5R each, one winner at 20R, and 31 losers at 1R. The profit factor is 47 / 31 = 1.52, the win rate 38%, and the implied payoff 2.47, which the formula recovers exactly.

Remove the single 20R trade. The profit factor drops to 27 / 31 = 0.87, and the expectancy goes from +0.32R a trade to about -0.08R. The typical winner was 1.5R all along; the report’s payoff described one trade, not the strategy.

So when the implied payoff looks large, ask for the largest win and the median win as well as the average.

7. What to ask for

The profit factor, the win rate and the trade count, so you can compute the implied payoff. The exit rules, stated completely, so you know the ceiling. The average win and average loss, as a second route to the same payoff. And the largest win, so you know whether the average is a description or an exception.

The order matters

Compute the payoff the report implies, read the exits, then compare the two. Done the other way round, starting from the equity curve, a profit factor of 1.5 looks like a modest, believable number. Set against a 2:1 bracket at 42% winners, it is a number the strategy as described cannot produce.

Every figure above is arithmetic on hypothetical reports, computed for this note. None of it is a result of mine.

These are the same checks I run before I believe any backtest, including my own.

Get the Backtest Verification Checklist

Historical simulations are not live results. Nothing on this site is investment advice.